Learning to See a City: Seven films worth watching
I have been thinking lately about how we come to know a city. Not the surface knowledge - which neighbourhood to stay in, which piazza to walk through at dusk - but the deeper thing: how a city actually feels from the inside, the particular emotional weather it generates in the people who move through it day after day. That knowledge, usually, takes years. Sometimes, a film can give it to you in two hours.
Not a documentary. Not a travel film in any conventional sense. I mean something more specific: those rare films so saturated in their location that the city stops being a setting and becomes a condition. The kind of film where, if you moved the action to another city, nothing would work - not the plot, not the mood, not what it means to be alone there rather than somewhere else. Films where place is as much a character as any person on screen.
I have seen many films that did this for me - that gave me a city, fully and irreversibly, before or after I arrived. I have been trying to understand what they share.
Rome: La Grande Bellezza
Sorrentino’s The Great Beauty arrived in 2013 and, for anyone who had spent time in Rome, felt immediately, disarmingly true. Not documentary true - Sorrentino’s Rome is heightened, operatic, slightly unreal. But emotionally true. Morally true, even.
The film follows Jep Gambardella, a journalist in his sixties who wrote one celebrated novel forty years ago and has spent the decades since attending parties. He moves through Rome’s terraced rooftops and abandoned villas and crumbling palazzi in a state of beautiful, ironised melancholy - surrounded by people performing lives, including himself. At the centre of it is Rome itself: ancient, indifferent, absurdly beautiful. A city that has been accumulating history for three thousand years and cannot take any individual human drama quite seriously because of it.
What Sorrentino understood is that Rome exerts a particular moral pressure on its inhabitants. The weight of what has happened in every building, on every street, is so immense that it makes ordinary ambition look faintly ridiculous. The city doesn’t argue with you. It simply waits. In time, you either leave or you cultivate a different kind of ambition - the ambition of pleasure, of conversation, of the long dinner, the late walk. Jep has done this. Whether it is a magnificent way to live or a terrible waste, the film declines to say. Rome has seen too many people ask the same question.
I went back to Rome after seeing the film and found it, for the first time, slightly sinister. Not in a frightening way - in the way that great beauty can be sinister when you understand it doesn’t need you. I walked the streets at midnight, past the faded frescoes and the iron balustrades gone soft with rust, and understood that this city was not a backdrop. It had a point of view.
Milan: Io Sono l’Amore
Luca Guadagnino’s *I Am Love* is, on the surface, about a wealthy Milanese family in the years after they hand their textile business to the next generation. Beneath the surface, it is about what happens when one person in that family - Emma, the matriarch, played by Tilda Swinton with an almost supernatural precision - begins, slowly and then entirely, to feel.
But when I first watched the film, what I could not take my eyes off was the house.
It is vast and still. Panelled rooms that seem to absorb sound. A formal garden glimpsed through tall windows. Staircases that nobody hurries on. Guadagnino uses it not as a backdrop but as an argument - the house embodies everything the family has built and everything it costs to live inside that perfection.
For years I assumed it was a set, or some private palazzo opened for the shoot and closed again. It was only later - actually in Milan, walking through the Porta Venezia neighbourhood - that I discovered it was real. The Villa Necchi Campiglio, designed by architect Piero Portaluppi in the 1930s: a modernist house of extraordinary discipline and beauty, now owned by the FAI, the Italian national trust, and open to visit. I stood outside and felt the particular excitement of finding that something you had imagined as fiction had been standing in a city all along, waiting to be found. I have been back nearly every time I visit Milan since.
What the film taught me about Milan was how to read its surface correctly. Before, I saw the restraint and thought it was coldness. After, I understood it as containment. The emotion was always there. The city simply required a certain form. There is something about the Milanese commitment to beauty - in design, in food, in how a table is set - that is not aesthetic vanity. It is a belief that the outer life shapes the inner one.
Five More Worth Seeing
These are not the only films that do this. A guidebook tells you where to go; a great film tells you how to *see* - how to read the mood of a street, the significance of an interior, the emotional logic of a place. Here are five others I keep returning to.
In the Mood for Love (Wong Kar-wai, 2000) - Hong Kong. Two neighbours in 1962, separated by a thin wall, discover that their spouses are having an affair with each other. Wong Kar-wai shoots almost entirely in compressed corridors and stairwells - we see very little of Hong Kong from outside - and in doing so captures something essential about a city built for density, for proximity, for lives conducted at very close quarters. The longing in the film is inseparable from the architecture. You cannot be this close to someone and feel nothing.
Kedi (Ceyda Torun, 2016) - Istanbul. A documentary about the street cats of Istanbul, which is also, quietly, one of the most attentive portraits of a city ever made. The cats move through neighbourhoods, between fishmongers and tea houses and crumbling Ottoman courtyards, and the film follows them with a kind of patient curiosity that slowly reveals the texture of a city most travel writing fails to find. Istanbul seen from two feet off the ground.
Lost in Translation (Sofia Coppola, 2003) - Tokyo. Two Americans adrift in a city they cannot read - the neon, the game shows, the capsule hotels, the vast silent lobbies of a luxury hotel at three in the morning. Coppola is not interested in explaining Tokyo; she is interested in what it feels like to be a foreigner inside it, overwhelmed and exhilarated in equal measure. The film captures something specific about Tokyo’s particular combination of extreme order and extreme strangeness, and the unexpected intimacy that can form between people who are both, equally, lost.
Wings of Desire (Wim Wenders, 1987) - Berlin. Angels drift invisibly through a divided city, listening to the inner thoughts of its inhabitants. Wenders shot in black and white for the angels’ view and colour for the human one - and the Berlin he found, in the years just before the Wall came down, is a city carrying the full weight of what happened to it. A film about listening, about the specific gravity of a specific place at a specific moment. The city it captures no longer exists.
Before Sunrise (Richard Linklater, 1995) - Vienna. Jesse and Céline meet on a train and spend a single night walking through the city together - the trams, the cafes, a wine bar in a basement, the Prater at dusk, the Danube at dawn. Linklater shoots Vienna with almost no artifice: it is simply the place two people happen to be, and yet by the end of the film it is inseparable from everything they felt there. The city becomes the container of a particular kind of conversation, and of the particular hope that comes from staying up all night with someone who surprises you. Vienna has never seemed more worth visiting.
I am still not sure whether a film teaches you to see a city, or whether it simply gives you the vocabulary for what you already, dimly, felt when you were there. Perhaps it doesn’t matter. What I know is that I have walked into cities carrying these films, and found them waiting - exactly as described, and entirely unexpected.
The best travel is still the kind that changes what you see. It turns out you do not always have to be on a plane for that to happen.
The Leopard